The Top Tier is for stuff that’s pretty fucking great when comparing to other fanfiction, but has enough problems that I probably wouldn’t recommend it to anyone not already in the fanfiction-sphere. Note: The placement of Spoonful of Sugar by DarknessEnthroned in this tier is a severely out of date decision that I no longer stand by. It belongs in Crusade, I just haven’t gotten around to rereviewing it yet.
- I Know Not, and I Cannot Know; Yet I Live and I Love by billowsandsmoke
- For Lack of a Bezoar by BolshevikMuppet99
- A Spoonful of Sugar by DarknessEnthroned
- Moratorium by Darkpetal16
- Limpieza de Sangre by TheEndless7
- The Quidditch World Cup by TheEndless7
- Easier than Falling Asleep by JacobApples
- Harry Potter and the Secrets in the Shadows by Mr 3CP
- The Other Champion by Srikanth1808
- The Prince of Slytherin TheSinisterMan
- Fellowship of the Potters by Ubiquitouslyverbose
- Lunar Calendar by Ubiquitously Verbose